High-income and executive divorces technically ride the same legal framework as any other divorce, but the reality behind it feels more complicated.
The most recent preliminary data from the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention place the number of divorces and annulments at 672.502 in 2023. Multiple petitions were filed during the same time frame, some of which are referred to as executive & high-income divorces. In this type of divorce, the assets are harder to pin down for valuation and the money at risk is substantially higher.
The matters that keep coming up in these cases involve the courts’ handling of executive compensation and the appraisal of business interests. This type of divorce usually covers income figures that end up governing alimony and how the 2018 tax law changes affect the overall settlement design. They depend on the specifics of how the parties structured compensation, when the parties acquired assets and which state’s law governs the proceeding.
Let’s go over some of the common issues associated with executive and high-income divorce.
What Gets Divided in Executive Compensation and What Doesn’t
Base salary is the least complicated component of an executive’s income. The rest requires analysis. Executives typically receive compensation through structures that do not produce immediate, visible income. Each of these structures raises distinct questions about what portion belongs to the marriage.
Restricted stock units (RSUs) and stock options granted during the marriage typically count as marital property, but vesting schedules complicate matters. Courts often apply a proration formula to units that vest after the divorce, allocating the marital share based on how much of the vesting period occurred while the parties were married. Parties can divide the unvested portion on a deferred basis or buy it out at a present value.
Performance bonuses earned during the marriage typically count as marital property. Even a bonus announced in December and paid in January after a divorce proceeding can still be subject to division, depending on the state’s rules about when income counts as earned versus received.
Settlement negotiations often overlook deferred compensation plans, in which an executive elects to defer a portion of current income to be paid out in future years. These plans can represent substantial value and have specific tax treatment that is not always divisible through a standard qualified domestic relations order (QDRO) in the same way that a pension or 401(k) is.
Golden parachute provisions and change-in-control payments are contingent benefits that companies may or may not award depending on future corporate events. Courts treat these differently depending on whether the triggering event had already occurred at the time of divorce. Failing to identify these components entirely can mean leaving substantial value undiscovered.
As one analysis of executive compensation in divorce noted, basing asset division or alimony requests on base salary alone, rather than total compensation, can substantially undervalue a party’s financial position. You can refer to the IRS guidance on deferred compensation and divorce for relevant tax treatment rules.
According to Orange County high-asset divorce lawyer Stephane Quinn, favorable settlements are rarely achieved through compromise alone. Complex divorce cases often settle because both sides recognize that the case is fully prepared for trial if a fair agreement cannot be reached. Being ready to litigate can encourage more productive settlement negotiations.
Business Interests and the Valuation Problem
When an executive holds a substantial equity stake in a privately held company or owns a business directly, valuation becomes one of the most contested issues in the case. Unlike publicly traded stock with a daily market price, closely held business interests have no ready market value. The number depends on which valuation methodology someone applies and who is doing the analysis.
Appraisers typically rely on three primary approaches. The income approach values the business based on projected future earnings. The market approach, in contrast, evaluates the business by comparing it to sales of similar companies. The asset approach values the net assets on the balance sheet. Each method can produce a materially different result for the same company, and parties in high-income divorces routinely hire competing experts who reach different conclusions. When these conflicts arise, judicial authorities make a decision by measuring the different tests against one another.
There are certain cases where courts adopt a combined methodology. The AICPA, otherwise known as the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, is a standard-setting body whose business valuation standards are a critical reference point for forensic accountants tackling issues in divorce proceedings, among others.
Goodwill treatment raises a related issue, since courts divide it into personal goodwill attributable to the individual’s relationships and reputation. Enterprise goodwill is attributable to the business itself and is typically divisible.
In most states, personal goodwill is not marital property since it does not transfer to a buyer and cannot be separated from the individual. The distinction is frequently disputed and often relies on expert testimony about what would survive a hypothetical sale of the business without the owner’s continued involvement.
Spousal Support, Income Determination and the 2018 Tax Shift
Lifestyle analysis drives alimony in high-income divorces. Courts conduct a detailed assessment of what the couple spent during the marriage, not just of what income they earned, to establish the standard of living that support payments are intended to approximate. This analysis often involves forensic accountants reviewing years of tax returns, credit card statements and asset transaction records.
There have been significant changes regarding the taxation of spousal support in the USA. These changes have resulted from the amendments introduced in the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, as discussed in IRS Topic 452. This development has resulted in alimony no longer being deductible when a divorce is entered on or after December 31, 2018, by the person making payment. Instead, alimony is included in the income of the person receiving it.
The practical effect on settlement negotiation is significant. Under prior law, a high-income payer could deduct alimony payments, reducing the after-tax cost of support substantially. Under current law, however, there is no deduction.
Consider a payment of $200,000 per year in alimony, which now costs the payer the full $200,000 in after-tax dollars rather than the reduced effective amount a deduction would have produced. This shifts the negotiating posture in many high-income divorces, as payers have less financial incentive to agree to large support amounts when no deduction offsets the obligation.
Executive divorces also involve a separate and frequently overlooked issue known as double-dipping. This is the principle that a business interest should not both count as divided property and serve as the income base for ongoing alimony. Courts in most states recognize some version of this rule but its application varies.
Courts cannot always require an executive who transfers equity in a business to a spouse as part of the property settlement to also pay alimony calculated on the income that same business generates, since the receiving spouse now owns a share of that income-producing asset.
What High-Income Divorce Requires That Other Divorces Don’t
The defining characteristic of executive and high-income divorce is the extent of expert involvement required to reach an accurate outcome. Forensic accountants, business valuators, financial advisors and tax specialists all contribute to cases that courts cannot resolve accurately without expert analysis.
The Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute’s overview of equitable distribution provides foundational context on how courts approach property division, but the application of those principles to deferred compensation, unvested equity and privately held business interests requires expertise that goes well beyond general legal knowledge.
Identifying and fully valuing all components of executive compensation, before negotiation begins, is the most consequential step in protecting financial interests in these cases.
